Hospitality · Buying

Cap Rates Don't Tell the Whole Story: Buying a Lodge in Estes Park

Six things I look at before I'd call a mountain lodging property a good buy.

When a lodge, motel or cabin property comes up for sale in Estes Park, the first number everyone asks for is the cap rate. I get it. It's quick, it's easy to compare, and lenders look at it too.

But I ran Ponderosa Realty & Management here in Estes Park for about 20 years, handling vacation rentals, long-term rentals and brokerage. From the operator's side of the desk, I can tell you the cap rate is where the conversation starts, not where it ends. Here's what I look at before I'd tell a client a mountain lodging property is worth the price.

1. Seasonality: when does the money actually come in?

Estes Park is the gateway to Rocky Mountain National Park, and summer and early fall are our busy months. A trailing twelve-month number smooths all of that out. What it hides is that a big share of the year's revenue can arrive in a few months, while the mortgage, utilities, insurance and payroll show up every month.

So I want to see revenue by month, not just by year. That tells you how much cash it takes to carry the property through the slow months, and whether the shoulder seasons are getting stronger or weaker.

2. Is the owner's labor in the numbers?

A lot of smaller lodges are owner-operated. The owner works the front desk, keeps the books and fixes the ice machine at 10 p.m. That time often never shows up on the P&L, which makes the net income look better than what a new owner would see if they hired the work out.

When I review financials, I ask what it would cost to replace the owner's time, and then I adjust the income to match. FYI, buyers and lenders will do this math either way, so sellers are better off doing it first.

3. Add-backs: real or wishful?

Seller financials usually come with add-backs: depreciation, interest, one-time repairs, personal expenses run through the business. Some of those are completely fair. Others are a stretch. A new roof really is a one-time expense, but if the boiler goes the next year and the water heaters the year after, "one-time" starts to look like a pattern.

I go through each add-back with one question in mind: would a new owner really never see this cost again?

4. Capital reserves and deferred maintenance

Mountain buildings take a beating. Snow load, freeze and thaw, decks, roofs, older mechanical systems, and on some properties wells and septic. A property can show a great cap rate simply because the owner hasn't put money back into it.

I like to walk the property with the buyer and an inspector and put a rough number on what's likely to come due in the next five years. Then we see what that does to the return.

5. Staffing and housing

Finding housekeepers and maintenance help in a mountain town is one of the hardest parts of running a lodging property. I am guessing anyone who has owned one here would agree. So I ask: does the property include any employee housing? Is the current staff planning to stay? What happens to the operation if two key people leave the week after closing?

None of that shows up in a cap rate. All of it shows up in your first summer.

6. Licensing, zoning and water

Lodging and short-term rental rules in the Estes Valley come from the Town of Estes Park or Larimer County, depending on where the property sits, and they change from time to time. Before you count on any rental income, confirm that the property's current licensing and zoning allow the use you have in mind.

The same goes for water and sewer. Who provides service, what the taps allow and whether there's capacity for more matter a lot, especially if your plan is to add units.

A quick example

These are made-up properties, just to show the idea. Say two lodges are listed at the same price and the same cap rate.

Lodge ALodge B
Who runs itOwner, about 60 hours a week, unpaidManager on payroll
Roof and boilerOriginal, near the end of their lifeReplaced recently
StaffSeasonal, hired fresh each springCore crew with housing

On paper they look the same. In real life, Lodge B is the better buy, and Lodge A should come with a lower price to cover the labor and the repairs you're about to pay for.

The bottom line

A cap rate is a fine place to start. But a mountain lodge is an operating business wrapped around real estate, and you want to underwrite it like an owner who has to run it on a Tuesday in March. That's the lens I bring to every deal I work on.

If you're looking at a lodge, motel, cabin property or vacation rental portfolio in the Estes Valley, I'd like to hear about it. What kind of property are you looking for?

Want more on this? See my pages on lodging and hospitality property and selling a lodge in Estes Park.

← All posts

The Talk to Seth newsletter

Get my monthly notes on Estes Park commercial property

Once a month I share what I'm seeing in lodging, vacation rentals and income property around Estes Park and Northern Colorado, from someone who has run these properties, not just sold them. Short, useful and free.

Sign up for the newsletter Free. Unsubscribe anytime.

Talk to Seth

Thinking about buying or selling?

Give me a call, send a text or drop me an email. Tell me about the property, or what you're looking for, and I'll tell you honestly what I see.

(970) 310-9778